A mailing list for your online store: how to collect email addresses legally
Updated: 11 November 2026
Visitors who come once and leave without buying are usually gone for good. If you get their email address, you can remind them of your store when it matters, for example during a sale or before Christmas. Here is how to build a mailing list.
The rules first
The general rule in Iceland is that marketing emails are not allowed when there is no business relationship between the parties. So you need consent from people who aren't customers. Customers also always have the right to object, and that must be respected.
In practice: don't pre-tick marketing consent, say what people are signing up for and include an unsubscribe link in every email.
1. A discount for an email address
A popup offering, say, 10% off the first order in exchange for an email address is the most common approach. Show it after a few seconds or when the visitor is about to leave, not the moment the page opens.
2. Back in stock alerts
When a product is sold out, the customer can leave their email and get a message when it's back. These are people with clear interest, and the email is a service they asked for.
3. At checkout
In Shopify's checkout, customers can tick a box to receive marketing emails. Make sure it isn't pre-ticked.
What to send
- A welcome email right away, with the discount code if one was promised.
- New products and offers, but not too often. Once or twice a month is a good start.
- Reminders before big days: Black Friday, Christmas and Mother's Day.
- Always an unsubscribe link.
Take care of the list
Email addresses are personal data. Use them only for the purpose people agreed to, and stop emailing anyone who unsubscribes right away.
More guides
- Black Friday in a Shopify store: a 2026 checklist
- Last order date for Christmas: how to set delivery deadlines in your online store
- Shopify in Icelandic: how to translate your online store
- Shipping in Shopify in Iceland: Pósturinn, Dropp and store pickup
- Gift wrapping in an online store: should you charge for it and how to offer it?
- Sales calendar 2027: Icelandic occasions online stores should use
- Payments in Shopify in Iceland: which payment gateways work?
- VAT (VSK) in Shopify: how to set 24% and 11% correctly
- Cookies in Shopify: what does an Icelandic online store need to do?
- Prices in euros and dollars: how to help tourists understand your prices
- Higher average order value: 6 ways to sell more to the same customers
- An AI chat assistant in your online store: is it worth it?